ISLAM AND HUMOUR – PART 5 – THE EVOLUTION OF THE INDIAN RESTAURANT SKETCH

Following on from Islam and Humour parts 1, 2, 3, and 4


Racism is a very complex issue indeed. And that is a very heavy opening sentence. Whilst there are many ways to analyse racism, be it academically, culturally, politically, etc, I recently discovered a slightly quirkier way of plotting the evolution of racism towards those from sub-continental India, and that is by looking at how the good old Indian restaurant is viewed in the field of comedy.

The first appearance of curry on a menu in Britain was at the Coffee House in Haymarket, London in 1773. However the first establishment fully dedicated to Indian cuisine was the Hindostanee Coffee House at Portman Square, London in 1809, as recorded in The Epicure’s Almanack (the first ‘good food guide’ of its kind). It was opened by a Bengali named Saik Deen Mahomad from Patna, Bihar, India, via Cork in Ireland (no, I’m not sure how that works either). Mahomad appreciated all things Indian and offered a house “for the Nobility and Gentry where they might enjoy the Hookha with real Chilm tobacco and Indian dishes of the highest perfection.”

Whilst the Hindostanee Coffee House closed a few years later, today however no British high street is complete without a decent Indian restaurant: “going for an Indian” is now as quintessentially British as “going for a pint”. Some even consider chicken tikka masala to be the unofficial national dish of Britain. Taking this one step further, I would consider chips and curry sauce to be the unofficial national dish of students in Britain, although I still have no clue as to what type of curry that particular sauce is made from.

Indian restaurants are not only on our high streets, they are also in our comedy programs. Below are links to three comedy sketches, all set in Indian restaurants, that display (rather vaguely, I know) the evolution of racism in Britain.


We start with typically racist fare…

The first sketch is from the Two Ronnies, who are a classic British comedy institution. They have been very popular on British television for decades now, and continue to be as popular as ever.

This particular sketch is known unofficially as ‘The Pink Rupee Rap’ and, I am guessing from the décor and certain cultural references, is from the early 1980’s.

Despite the clever word play (which you always expect from the Two Ronnies) I consider this to be rather racist and insensitive as both Ronne Barker and Ronnie Corbett have ‘browned’ themselves up, one of them is called Ram-Jam, their accents leave plenty to be desired, and they have such silly expressions on their faces throughout.

I’m sure the intention is not to offend (it never is, as the offenders always counter) but a sketch like this would never see the light of day in our more politically correct times.

There is apparently a longer version than the one shown below which I could not source, a version that has the lyric in it of “Nana Mouskouri loves my tandoori.” Unfortunately lost for ever in the archives!

The Two Ronnies – The Pink Rupee Rap


We move on to something a little more positive…

The second sketch is a few years on from the Pink Rupee Rap, and features a solo effort from Rowan Atkinson as an endlessly patient waiter in an Indian restaurant, serving an imagined group of nine drunk English football fans. Known officially as “Guys After The Game”, on the internet it is better known as “Indian Waiter”.

Whilst Rowan Atkinson’s performance is hilarious, as you would expect from such a seasoned comedy veteran, he does thankfully keep his natural skin colour, but he does support a dodgy accent similar to the one adopted by the Two Ronnies. This sketch, however, is not as offensive as the previous one because the only really clever person is the waiter himself and it is the clientele who are the butt of the overall joke. Also there are several clever lines in there, such as the floor being described as “deceptively flat” after one of the drunks trips over.

Rowan Atkinson – Drunk English In Indian Restaurant


We end on the ultimate Indian restaurant sketch…

So far we’ve gone from silly stereotypically type-casted Indian waiters, to an Indian waiter making subtle fun of stereotypically white drunks. The final sketch picks up the comedy gauntlet and runs to the finish line, by turning these two sketches on their satirical heads.

The television program Alexei Sayle’s “Stuff” in the early 1990’s included a brief monologue where the residents of New Delhi got drunk and ate steak and kidney pies on a Friday night. The comedy sketch show Goodness Gracious Me went further than Alexei Sayle. In the late 1990’s they came up with their most famous sketch, “Going For An English.”

This sketch is still a classic yet modern parody of cultures and behaviours nearly 20 years on. It begins with a satirical 1970’s style cinema advert for the restaurant Mountbatten’s English Cuisine, complete with badly filmed and heavily scratched images, and then launches into the actual sketch itself.

Its cleverness rests in a total scene reversal. The ethnic minority becomes the dominant culture, such that we are no longer in England but in India, we are “going for an English” instead of “going for an Indian”, the restaurant itself is English not Indian, the clientele are Indian not English, and the staff are the ones who are foreigners, being English not Indian.

It is this cultural and comical inversion that says something about British society that perhaps was not really seen previously. The sketch asks the viewer to consider how patronising and embarrassing things can be when viewed from another angle. By using some cleverly worded interplay between clientele and staff, the sketch sends up the typical behaviour of many English people in Indian restaurants, all from an Indian perspective. Because stereotypes are subverted, the dominant become the dominated, and white viewers come to realise what it feels like to be treated in the way that white people commonly treat Indian restaurant staff.

The sketch was voted the 6th greatest comedy sketch on Channel 4’s 50 Greatest Comedy Sketches (a sketch from Little Britain was number one, in case you’re wondering, which you probably are).

Two versions are presented below, the original one from the television series, and a slightly different version from the 2001 Amnesty International We Know Where You Live, Live concert in Wembley, London.

Goodness Gracious Me – Going For An English

Going Out For An English – Amnesty International Concert London


As an added bonus, I found this really bizarre sketch of Michael Palin playing an Indian waiter. Not sure what to make of it!

How To Irritate People – “Restaurant”

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “ISLAM AND HUMOUR – PART 5 – THE EVOLUTION OF THE INDIAN RESTAURANT SKETCH

  1. The only way to deal with a racism is to ignore it exist and rise above it. Indian accent is funny for everyone out side South East Asia and people will laugh at the accent. It’s a natural response just like In India people can’t stop laughing when European visitors try to speak Hindi or other Indian languages. People of other culture always get mocked in comedy or films. In Indian films white people are depicted as drug smugglers and people with lose character because of their assumed free attitudes toward sex. Does it hurt white people? well I haven’t seen any complaining directly to me.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I think that we should never lose the ability to laugh at ourselves and ignore the minority who will use our differences against us. Accents are amusing. I love asking someone with a Scottish accent to say ‘Burglar Alarm’ (Reference Kevin Bridges stand up). 😛

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s